The more accurately the goal is set, the further away from greatness? Read "Why Greatness Cannot Be Planned"
Skip to main content

The more accurately the goal is set, the further away from greatness? Read "Why Greatness Cannot Be Planned"

A traveler stands on a stepping stone in the river, looking at the winding stone path ahead, with a glowing vacuum tube placed on one of the stones

There is only one formula for success taught to us by teachers or experts since childhood: first set goals, then break down milestones, and finally grit your teeth and execute them. I also teach this set of formulas myself. I write them down in briefings and include them in courses. Most of the students who listen to them nod their heads.

So, when I read the first chapter of “Why Greatness Cannot Be Planned (opens in a new tab)”, I was a little restless. Two authors, Kenneth. Kenneth O. Stanley and Joel. Joel Lehman has worked for OpenAI, and their experimental results using AI research told me: When the goal is ambitious enough, the goal-oriented method is prone to failure.

The English version of this book was published as early as 2015, and it has long been famous in the AI ​​research circle. Economic New Trends Press launches a Chinese version this time, translated by Wu Weisheng. I think reading it now is the right time.

An AI experiment overturned a set of management theories

The starting point of the story is Picbreeder (opens in a new tab), a picture experiment website created by Stanley. The user picks a picture he likes and lets it “breed” into the next generation, and then others take over and continue to pick.

The two discovered a strange thing: the most exciting works on the website almost always appear when the user has no specific goal. People who deliberately want to reproduce a certain picture often fail. People who wander around out of curiosity actually produce amazing works.

They wrote this discovery into an algorithm and called it novelty search. Let the robot walk through a maze without telling it where the end point is, and only reward it for behavior it has never done before. As a result, its performance in getting out of the maze was actually better than the traditional method of staring at the end point.

The reason is called deceptive in the book. The step closest to the end in a maze is often a dead end; the real way out is to go around in the opposite direction first. Just looking at how far you are from the end, you will run into a corner and think you are making progress.

The stepping stone does not look like the destination

Full Book (opens in a new tab) My favorite concept is stepping stones.

The vacuum tube was not made to invent the computer, but it was an important key to the birth of the computer. Rock music is not a goal set by anyone. It grew out of jazz and blues. If someone had written “inventing the computer” into the annual KPI back then, he probably wouldn’t have spent time on vacuum tubes, because it seemed to have nothing to do with computers.

This means something uncomfortable: the most critical steps on the road to greatness can seem like a waste of time right now.

When I look back at my own path, I see the same thing. For example, when I was still working in the Internet industry, because I was very interested in the media ecosystem, I forced myself to understand it and even tried to contribute articles. Later, I became a media person as I wished.

It’s not just students who are kidnapped by indicators.

The author points his finger at three places: education, scientific research and business innovation.

The education part is easy to understand. Standardized testing turns teaching into test training and students into testing machines.

The section on scientific research was the most touching to me. The book points out that the peer review system favors consensus and measurable results, and it is difficult for truly avant-garde ideas to pass the test. In the past few years, I have accompanied graduate students in writing papers and watched the submission (opens in a new tab) process, and I can well understand this tension: research plans must state the expected results before they can get funding, but the most valuable discoveries are often not within expectations.

The same goes for business. When a company ties all its resources to quarterly targets, it only has to make existing things better, and it is difficult to grow something completely new. There is a sentence in the first chapter of the book that I copied: “Sometimes, the best way to change the world is not to try to change it.”

This book does not tell you to lose your goals

After reading this, you may be worried that this is a book that advocates living casually. In fact, the authors make it very clear that they distinguish between modest goals and ambitious goals.

Paying in reports, handing in projects, or preparing for next week’s class, these daily tasks still require planning (opens in a new tab), and the goals are still valid. Where goals fail are those things where you don’t even know what the end point looks like: innovation, discovery, breakthrough, and where you want to go in the next ten years of your life.

The alternative proposed by the author is called treasure hunter thinking. A treasure hunter doesn’t know where the treasure is, so he doesn’t draw a road map. He only does three things: follow interesting and novel clues, collect as many stepping stones as possible, and accept that he doesn’t know where he will go.

After reading this, I will use it like this

The greatest value of this book is that it gives “exploration” a legitimate position. Here are three things I plan to do and recommend to you:

  1. Carve out a block of your calendar. Set aside some time each week to do something that has nothing to do with any KPI but that you find interesting. No output required, no reporting required.
  2. Keep a log of your stepping stones. Make a list of new things you have tried recently, whether they were successful or not. Looking back half a year later, you will notice which stones are beginning to connect into a road.
  3. Share what you learn. In her endorsement, Audrey Tang described how on Picbreeder, one person shares an image, a stranger picks it up, then another, until it grows into something no one had imagined. The note (opens in a new tab) you published today may be a stepping stone for others.

In the AI ​​​​era, it is increasingly easy to hand over planning to machines, but exploration still has to rely on humans. If you have recently felt that your goals are getting clearer and clearer, but your days are getting narrower and narrower, this book is worth reading over the weekend.


Book Title: Why Greatness Can’t Be Planned: Breaking the Goal Myth and the Surprising Power of Free Exploration Author: Kenneth. Stanley, Joel. Lehman Translator: Wu Weisheng Publisher: Economic News Society Publication date: November 7, 2026

Next step

Bring this topic to your team

Vista Cheng speaks and runs workshops on AI workflows, writing and content systems for companies, schools and public agencies.